X

Our Analysts' Insights

06Dec

Build Versus Buy for LSPs - Its When, Not if

From their earliest stages, LSPs face the question of whether to build or buy the software on which they run their business. Triggers can include the need for differentiation, the need to tailor work processes for different customers and job types, or the requirement to stitch together disparate systems for monitoring and reporting. The question of when to begin proprietary development is important because if they wait too long, they may miss growth opportunities. But jumping too soon can result in unfocused and wasted effort.

Interviews and analysis for a recent CSA Research report led us to conclude that LSPs must start developing software – if they hope to get to full maturity. We interviewed CEOs and CTOs at language service providers about their technology adoption patterns, then compared their plans to the LSP Metrix™ maturity model (see Figure).
 

We discovered that Stage 4 (Responsive) companies demand control and reporting capabilities on substantially all work they perform for clients. That means that they must figure out how to pull status and other project information from multiple commercial platforms for translation (TMSes) as well as interpreting management systems (IMSes). No TMS nor IMS can manage or report on projects being processed in another system, so monitoring work processes and gathering intelligence in multiple systems becomes a drag on operations and an obstacle to growth.

In earlier stages, LSPs experiment with low-risk development exercises such as filters, scripts, and other utilities for file processing, or increasingly progressive adaptation of open-source solutions. Then they move on to building discrete applications from the ground up. By the time they approach Stage 4 (Responsive), they face a bigger challenge -- integrating the reporting and control functions from the multiple TMSes and IMSes that they use to satisfy the needs of their diverse clientele.

At this stage, even the most cautious LSPs must take the plunge and start writing their own code. They build proprietary cross-TMS/IMS control components to enable what CSA Research identified as the company operating system (COS), to monitor and report on multiple production platforms or business units. The COS may include commercial components, but proprietary development is needed to create a cross-platform layer not currently supported by off-the-shelf solutions. Without this operational layer, they can’t achieve the responsiveness required to graduate to Stage 5 (Adaptive).

We are sure that there are exceptions to this pattern and that some ambitious software vendors, Plunet and Smartling among them, could still add this missing cross-platform layer. However, for now the only LSPs we find operating with this level of maturity build important parts if not all of their core system.

While it is always advisable to use commercial tools over sub-par bespoke systems, LSPs need to gain experience in software development. When should they start? CEOs and technology leaders can make better decisions on what and when to build by using the combined analysis and maturation roadmap provided by the LSP Metrix and the tech-savvy LSP typology.

About the Author

Benjamin Sargent

Benjamin Sargent

Member of the Technology Advisory Board

Focuses on translation management systems and content management technologies

Related

Resuming Business in a COVID-19 Economy: Insight from 14 CEOs

Resuming Business in a COVID-19 Economy: Insight from 14 CEOs

The last few months have been tough on everyone. After a couple months of indecision, many political...

Read More >
China Shows the Way into the Post-COVID-19 Future

China Shows the Way into the Post-COVID-19 Future

In late April and early May, CSA Research partnered with the Institute of Language Services, Hebei N...

Read More >
Preparing Your Business for a Post-Pandemic World: The Team Factor

Preparing Your Business for a Post-Pandemic World: The Team Factor

After taking temporary measures and expedients to continue operating during the pandemic, companies ...

Read More >
Expanding Premium Customer Experiences

Expanding Premium Customer Experiences

Loyalty will rise to the fore after the COVID-19 pandemic runs its course. People will remember the ...

Read More >
Profiles of Interpreting-Focused LSPs in Times of COVID-19

Profiles of Interpreting-Focused LSPs in Times of COVID-19

The COVID-19 crisis has hit interpreting-focused language service providers particularly hard. Those...

Read More >
Caring for the Linguist Supply Chain

Caring for the Linguist Supply Chain

In a separate blog post ("AB5, COVID-19, and the Plight of Freelance Linguists"), we exami...

Read More >

Subscribe

Name

Categories

Follow Us on Twitter